Book Reviews



Formula One - The Real Score?, by Brian Godfrey Harvey.
ISBN: 978-1-787110-27-4, £45.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
Talk about modern Formula 1 and records focusses on the races - how many races a driver has competed in, how many pole positions a driver has, how many wins. But this relentless focus on statistics necessarily favours the modern drivers - there are over 20 Grands Prix a year in which to accumulate your statistics, whereas the Formula 1 World Championship of 1955, for example, only featured seven. How can they possibly ever accumulate the same totals, especially when the points awarded have suffered a severe bout of inflation, with 20 now being awarded for a win compared to 9, and points down to 10th compared to 6th?

But if you take a closer look at the 1955 season, for example, there may have only been seven World Championship Grands Prix (or Grands Epreuve as they were sometimes known - Argentina, Monaco, Indianapolis 500, Belgium, Netherlands, Great Britain and Italy), but there were actually 24 Grands Prix that year, as there were 17 non-championship races, races which is some cases were of greater stature than the Grands Epreuve. For example, Stirling Moss, who competed in six Grands Epreuve, also competed in six non-championship races, doubling the number of races that he actually competed in. If all F1 Grands Prix were considered, how would that affect the statistics? That is where this book comes in.

It aims to consider all F1 races and their equivalents (but makes no mention even in passing of the Aurora F1 series, so misses the only woman to have won a F1 race - Desire Wilson), and assigns them a rank of importance. Having done so, it then goes through year by year all of the races it is considering, giving a short result and description of all the major races, and a summation for each year. As you read through the book you get a feel for the authors preferences, but that is no bad thing - the descriptions are accurate, and interesting conclusions are drawn. There are also two interesting photo sections, which show how F1 design changed over time, and cover drivers not normally seen, such as Jean Pierre Wimille, who lost his life before he could trouble the world championship statisticians.

The book is an antidote to the endless stream of F1 statistic/results books which only ever cover the world championship races - the ones you are usually given by well meaning relatives at Christmas because they were seen on the shelf in the high street. It's almost that time of year again, time to drop some hints.....



Alfa Romeo Tipo 33: The development and racing history, by Peter Collins and Ed McDonough.
ISBN: 978-1-787111-31-8, £45.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
It's been a busy year for the Veloce Classic Reprint Series, and this is another well researched effort from Peter Collins and Ed McDonough which was originally published in 2005. The book starts with a timely warning about the difficulties of researching an accurate history of the various chassis used, not helped by the lack of Alfa/Autodelta record keeping, and then clarifies the approach that will be used. And it works - the authors are open about what is known and what is not, and document the anomalies. It's as accurate as can be.

The Tipo 33 lasted over a decade, but its life story raises an almost philosophical question - when is a car model still the same car model? If you start with one car, and over time change the chassis (more than once), the engine (likewise), the bodywork, and other sundry details one by one, is it still the same model at the end? All of this happened through the life of the T33, as it morphed from a classic curved 1960s sportscar into a slab-sided 1970s prototype. Each was called a T33, although there were numerous sub-model classifications, based on engine type (SC for Turbo, 12 for twelve cylinder) and chassis construction. And there were road cars and concept cars. All are covered within these pages.

The story is well sprinkled with anecdotes from drivers and test drivers, shedding light on how the car was viewed in period, although possibly coloured by the passing of the years, something the authors highlight themselves as they consider other possibly contradicting views. It could have done though with a little less use of "told the author" - that should be a given unless the quote is being taken from elsewhere. But that is a minor note from an otherwise informative read.

And one which is also well illustrated, with plenty of pictures (over 400 according to the blurb) of all the models highlighting the metamorphosis from promise to a world championship winner. With all the detail in this book, one wonders what extra could possibly go into a more extensive second book detailing the chassis histories which the authors reference as an effort for the future, which is probably why one hasn't yet appeared - the authors did a fine job the first time around.

Errata

PG44 - "Lucian Bianchias" - should read Lucien Bianchi.

PG95 - "one place ahead of Alfa driver, Elford, who was in a " - what? Sentence never finished.

PG206 - Sirius, Vega, Rigel and Aldebaran aren't just Italian names for stars - the same ones are used in English!



Lancia 037: The development and rally history of a World Champion, by Peter Collins.
ISBN: 978-1-787111-28-8, £45.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
Group B rallying is where it started for this reviewer. Lines of cars down Pulteney Street in Bath in 1986, waiting to take their starts, wandering in to the Hilton Hotel where rally control was to get a result sheet, and seeing Juha Kankkunen walking past. And best of all, Henri Toivonen visiting school with his car. But it wasn't to last - Toivonen wouldn't see out the year, and neither would Group B. But the cars were never to be forgotten.

And so this book was one to look forward to, part of the Veloce Classic Reprint series, covering a car of which I had previously read little, a stop-gap car which lived longer than intended, and achieved more than perhaps expected. And it didn't disappoint - the book details the gestation of the car, illustrated with copies of homologation papers, original technical drawings, copious photographs and very readable text. The author had extensive access to chief engineer Sergio Limone, and quotes comments extensively, as well as having comments and quotes from drivers such as Miki Biasion and Markku Alen, and pictures and documents from company archives. This is a book which all books covering a rally car should aspire to.

I liked the fact that there was a lack of hyperbole when describing the car and the results - the author had no need to use effusive words to emphasise results, when what was achieved in the context of the era was obvious in itself. The narrative is also not restricted to just rallying, and documents the participation of the car in various hillclimbs, Jim McGaughay's 037 based Special GT (a Toleman F2 chassis featuring a BMW engine, clothed in genuined 037 bodywork), as well as the road cars, coupled with a chassis list which states whether they were road cars, competition cars, and when known where they ended up.

The 037 overlapped with the Lancia Delta S4, and the origins of the car and the gradual change over is also covered. But full details of that is another story, and that is being published in November.....


Errata

PG 75 - "Andrea Zanussi, partnered by Bernard Chenne". According to pg 204, and other sources, he was partnered by A.Bernacchini.

PG 84 - Says that Pace rally was October 6th, should be 16th (as in table on pg 205)

PG 118 - Andruet's first win was the Rally du Rouergue on the 21st May, not Rally de la Baule.

PG 123 - Comment for photo of Biasion in Ypres '83 gives car reg, but this was for the Zanussi entry as stated on pg 122.

PG 160 - Rally Catalunya, says that Pons & Mandelli finished in "fifth and sixth places". Should be 4th and 5th, as per table on pg 210.

PG 206 - Missing Alen & Clarr from Costa Smeralda result list. Missing Rallye de la Baule & Andruet's win. There are other points from the main text not included here.

PG 207 - Blanc/Bubloz started #18 on Rally della Lana, not #6. Missing entries on 1985 Rally Terme di Casciana, 1985 Rally della Lanterna, 1985 Rally Città di Sassari, 1985 Rally di Pescara.....

PG 214 - Lists Criticos as #27 in Safari Rally, but photo on pg 185 confirms that Hellier was #27

PG 216 - Bianchi listed as #38 for 1986 Rally d'Antibes, was #18.



Ford GT: Then and now, by Adrian Streather.
ISBN: 978-1-787111-26-4, £45.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
Another from the Veloce Classic Reprint Series, this book was first published in 2006, which needs to be borne in mind when reading the text. Covering the Ford GT, it isn't just a review of the Ford GT from the late 1960s and early 1970s. It does that, but also introduces the new Ford GT created in the mid 2000s, which is where the reader needs to remember the first publishing date, as history has moved on since then.

At the time of publishing, the new Ford GT hadn't been raced, so it only covers the design and construction processes for it, and as there is so much good stuff on the original racing history, the book feels slightly unbalanced, probably more so knowing that the new Ford GT was raced. Mark VDS Racing won the 2009 Spa 24 Hrs with one, and one won the first ever FIA GT1 World Championship race at Abu Dhabi in 2010 (Roman Grosjean and Thomas Mutsch in a Matech entry). Hence I was going to suggest that the book could have benefitted from a revision rather than a simple reprint, but then I noticed on the last page of the book it documents a modern Ford GT replica which was inspired by the first edition of the book and was finished in 2016. If the first edition could have been updated, why not go the whole distance? Ford themselves created a new carbon fibre Ford GT which raced at Le Mans in 2016 and could have been mentioned, although admittedly this is a new from the ground up creation, and has no link to the original beyond being a Ford and having the same name.

The book doesn't just cover the factory Ford GTs created, but also goes on to document the numerous other companies which built replicas, or cars based on the original, which is something not often seen elsewhere. It also attempts to document some of the chassis histories, explaining how for some of the, two cars with the same chassis number can quite reasonably exist, and couples this with numerous photo's. It was informative to read how the author documents and classifies cars for historic racing purposes. There are also plenty of period photographs of the cars being raced, coupled with pictures detailing features such as cockpit layouts and carburettor setups.

However, I found some of the text slightly clumsy and confusing to the reader, with some meanings not being clear until later text cleared things up. There were also quite a few errata, although maybe some of them might not have been if the author could have clarified what his criteria were. For example, on page 80, the author writes that "The list of drivers killed in racing related accidents from 1963 to 1967 numbered thirty-five. [...] Along with the driver fatalities, five course marshals and nine spectators also lost their lives as a direct result of a race track incidents over the same time span.". Checking the website www.motorsportmemorial.org (10th August 2017), just for 1963 there were 102 motorsport related deaths, 39 on road courses, 51 on ovals. 71 drivers were killed, 16 spectators, and 3 marshals/support staff. It may be that the author was only referring to sportscar races, but the wording substantially underquotes the tragedies that happened during that period.

One thing though, the asking price for this reprint from Veloce is an absolute bargain compared to the £1909 asking price for two brand new first editions on Amazon as listed on the 17th August 2017 - even second hand ones were £100!

Errata/Issues

PG5 - Lists the nationality of Eric Liddell as (SCO), but Derek Bell (UK). Either both should be UK, or Derek Bell should be (ENG).

PG17 - "During 1964... and 12 hour endurance events at Reims and Nassau". The longest event of the 1964 Nassau Speed Week was 56 laps/405 km, just over 3 hours long.

PG23 - "finishing third during the 5-lap race in Nassau." There were two five-lap races, this refers to the over 2-litre race.

PG37 - Minor league results here would have been better shown in a table, as the text doesn't flow when trying to convey all the different points.

PG48 - Says that the 1966 Daytona 24 Hours was the "longest racing event ever held on US soil". Not based on time - 24 hour races were held as long ago as 1905 in the US, with 24 hour events held 34d-4th July 1905 at Columbus Driving Park, 16th-17th Novemebr 1905 at the Indiana State Fairgrounds, with further events in 1907 at Point Breeze, Grosse Point, Hamline, Maxwellton, Harlem (Chicago) and Brighton Beach. Did the author mean by distance?

PG74 - Crabbe/Pierpoint is #67 in the picture, not #57 as referred to in the text.

PG181 - Typo for South African track Kilarney - should be Killarney.

PG233-234 - Lists drivers alphabetically by first name, which is unusual, usually done by last name. Also randomly uses GB and UK as country codes, no consistency.



Autodrome: The lost race circuits of Europe, by S.S.Collins and Gavin D.Ireland.
ISBN: 978-1-787111-29-5, £45.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
First published in June 2005, this book is another re-issue in the Veloce Classic Reprint series. The idea behind it is simple - describe the history of circuits well known at the time but are no longer used, revisit them today, and take spectacular photographs. The book covers AVUS, Brooklands, Crystal Palace, Keimola, Masarykring (Brno), Montlhéry, Monza, Nürburgring Sudschleife and Reims. An eclectic mix, but strangely enough the least well known to me, Keimola, was the most interesting, as I haven't come across anything similar on this circuit anywhere else.

There are more detailed books on some of the individual circuits out there - Bill Boddy's books on Montlhéry and Brooklands for instance (although Boddy omits the ghost stories mentioned here), and Motor Sport covered Brno in a feature some years ago (in a little more detail, as the history on this circuit is strangely much lighter than for the others), but you would need multiple titles to cover the same ground. And the photography....

There are of course period photographs showing the circuits from the time they were used, but what makes the book stand out are Gavin Ireland's contemporary photo's, dripping with atmosphere and ghosts of time past. The use of low level sun and dusk to illuminate structures is cleverly done, and the cover shot from Reims and the sign-off shot from Montlhéry make you go back to look again and see what you missed. The cover shot in particular I'd like to see in an even larger format, to see all of the details bathed in the gentle orange glow of the sun.

There are many more lost circuits out there, but not many where you could really find the structures which help set the photographs apart in this book, so you can see why the number of tracks covered is relatively small - it was never intended to be an encyclopedia of track history. It was an enjoyable read which unearthed stories and facts not covered elsewhere.

Errata

PG4 - Spa-Franchorchamps - should be Spa-Francorchamps

PG37 - "The banked circuit saw occasional use during the 1960s and the Monzanapolis events were repeated." Should read "not repeated".

PG68 - The Nürburgring distances are slightly mixed up. It lists the Nordschleife as 14.2 miles/22.8 km, the Sudschleife as 4.8 miles/7.7 km, and the Gesamtstrecke as 17.5 miles/28.265 km. It then says in the next paragraph that "run over the full course" of 19 miles/28 km. The author has simply added together the Nordschleife and Sudschleife distances in miles, but 19 miles is not 28 km (see the Gesamtstrecke distances) - the circuits shared some track, and when used together came to the shorter 17.5 mile distance.



Cosworth: The Search For Power, by Graham Robson.
ISBN: 978-1-845848-95-8, £55.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
I liked this book the moment I unpacked it and saw the cover. As expected, given the history of Cosworth, the cover is dominated by F1, but where else would you see pictures of Ayrton Senna, Jim Clark, Michael Schumacher and Robb Gravett? And not hidden away either, just as prominent as the others, and a Ford RS200! Kudos to whoever designed that cover for doing something different.

Cosworth for me growing up meant the Ford RS500 touring car (the Ford RS200 was an odd thing piloted by Martin Schanche, and appeared once a year on BBC Grandstand when they showed the Brands Hatch rallycross grand prix), a massively powerful car that dominated its races. This was rapidly followed by the Sapphire Cosworth, a family car which would give a Ferrari a run for its money. All are covered in this book. It is weighty, published on thick paper, and there is a lot to read. So much so that I almost didn't finish reading it before the deadline I had given for writing this review.

The book covers Cosworth, so is appreciably different to the Duckworth autobiography reviewed earlier. It of course covers some of the same ground, but as it follows the company, the story diverges increasingly as time goes on. I appreciated the fact that the book was not F1 centered - of course it covers it, and well, and as Cosworth gave us the DFV how could it not, but it is only part of the story. There is a good description of CART history, describing much unknown work on engines raced by other concerns, as well as details of engine developments through the years for Ford. There is much that is new here for those who've only had European based news sources to keep up with the sport.

This is the 6th edition of this title, so allows the narrative to be updated and follow more recent topics. It is written in a style which is easy to read, and has lots of information interspersed with timely and illuminating anecdotes. For those with a more corporate interest, turnover figures are also given on a year by year basis. It really does follow the company, rather than just the people.

As the book gets more recent, it is increasingly struck by the curse of corporate secrecy, with fewer and fewer power outputs given, and more and more projects hinted at but not described, just a comment that we may get to know in future. This is reality, but frustrating at the same time. We can only hope that there is a future 7th edition which fills in these gaps, but then there will be new ones created, and so the cycle repeats....

Errata

PG164 - one typo - "listewning". And that's it, the book is well researched!



Lola: The Illustrated History 1957 to 1977, by John Starkey and Ken Wells.
ISBN: 978-1-787111-04-2, £37.50 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
Another of the Veloce Classic Reprint series, this is the second edition of a book first published in 1997. When the book was written, Lola was still a going concern, but in 2012 the company was finally wound up, with most of the assets purchased by Multimatic Engineering and Carl A.Haas Automotive Co. At least there was some link to the past with the purchasers, with Haas being a long term Lola importer and racer.

Having seen what author John Starkey did in his book Lola T70 - The Racing History & Individual Chassis Record, you could expect more of the same, but this book isn't to the same level of detail, and perhaps my views are slightly coloured by how good that book was. I'm not saying that this isn't a good book - it is - it just isn't a great one - it left me with a number of questions which I expected the book to have answered.

The author has a preference for big formula cars and sportscars when describing things - it goes through all of the different type numbers sequentially. However, on page 89 it gives a total of 122 words to cover the T200/202/204 formula ford cars, of which 120 were built. These were some of the most prolific models the company constructed - there were only 125 examples of other chassis/models constructed in the same period, so this was near enough half of everything built. The details were very light at this point, with no explanation of the differences between the three type variants. I found this disappointing given the level of detail elsewhere. For example, for larger formula cars individual chassis numbers are sometimes quoted, with details of racing through to historic racing. It's just a little inconsistent.

There are some great shots of the different cars, and it is easy to see the evolution of thought over time as you browse through the images. There are many exploded technical drawings of various components, which was great to see, and helps to show how complex and how much work goes into designing things. But why were they only for the T400 F5000 car? They are spread through the last third of the book, and as most pictures and diagrams are located near their respective text entries, you could be forgiven for thinking that they refer to other cars unless you read the footnotes carefully.

Some further questions which arose:-

  • Why do only German names have diacritics? The Österreichring and Nürburgring are correctly written, but others such as Angoulême and Lourenço Marques are not.
  • On PG96 it mentions the T230 from 1971 being an F1 car which was not built. Why? What was it meant to have been? There is no other mention in the text.
  • PG132 - Who was Jag, who span off at Silverstone? There was no mention of the driver before.

And when you finally get to pg 176 the text just stops. Having described the F3 T570, the book goes into a picture section of the cars in historic racing. There is no over-arching review of Lola and what it had achieved, of how the company had developed and what it was doing compared to others. It doesn't put Lola into context. The book is not a history of Lola, but it is a catalogue of the racing cars they built, and a list of who drove the more important ones.

I find myself getting to the end of this and being in two minds - I've given an account of the issues I had with it, but then find myself feeling that this is coming across far too negatively. I liked the book, it has loads of great detail, and rarely in one book do you ever see something covering so many different racing series across both Europe and the US (not forgetting Australasia and South Africa as well, as Lola cars competed in both the Tasman Series and the Springbok Series). I think that in the end what you should do is read this book before the Lola T70 one from the same author. Also consider that this is volume 1, and there is a second volume covering 1978 to 1997. Perhaps there needs to be a volume 3 covering 1997-2012.....

Errata

PG45 - Roger McClusky -> should read Roger McCluskey.

PG75 - Following seems to be a conjunction of two separate sentences: "Jackie Epstein found his experience with a T70 in 1966, when Paul Hawkins was driving his car in the first Can-Am events, meant that with the deletion of Group 7/9 racing he could use a Group 4 coupé based on Epstein had been racing a Ferrari 275LM in long-distance sportscar events....". Think it should be "...based on <something>. Epstein had been....", where "something" is a missing car designation, probably a T70 Spyder.

PG77 - Picture description - Carl Haa's should be Carl Haas'.

PG94 and 96 - Helmuth Marko, should be Helmut.

PG143 - Raupuna should be Ruapuna.

PG149 and 165 - Arlo Lawler should read Alo Lawler.



Lola T70 - The Racing History & Individual Chassis Record, by John Starkey.
ISBN: 978-1-787110-51-9, £35 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
This book is part of the Veloce Classic Reprint series, and is a fourth edition of a very well received book which has been revised with updated information for its chassis record. And what a chassis record - rarely have I seen something so detailed. Not content with just listing the chassis produced, it lists the gearbox numbers the cars were originally built with where known, the odd engine number, complete race results, post-period history and colour. It's a seriously impressive amount of research, and makes it the source for documenting these cars.

The book itself starts by describing the genesis of the T70, starting with the Ford GT40, and how Broadley moved on to create his own car based on his own ideals. It the moves through the five year front line career of the car, documenting the changes through Mark II, III and IIIb, as well as the T160, T162, T163 and T165 cars, which had a direct bearing on how the car developed. Liberally spread through the book are images of the cars at the various circuits around the world where it competed, together with many shots of the internals (anyone for fluid reservoirs, suspension uprights or engine bearers?), and documents showing car delivery specifications. Short of having an actual Haynes manual for the car, you couldn't do better. Included also are comments from contemporary drivers, and copies of track tests done in the past. It fully describes the car.

The author owned more than one T70 himself, and the passion for the car shows through, as every little detail which could be found has been added. The only possible thing to say against the book is that some of the images could be a little crisper, although I wasn't so sure about the chapter on historic racing. But this is definitely just a personal bias - I like to see the cars being driven, so that you can hear how they sounded, and feel more of the impact, but the actual racing doesn't interest me so much, nor does the fettling of the cars on newer rubber so that they go better than they ever did in period. If they weren't raced though people wouldn't maintain them, and the cars wouldn't be seen, so it's something to live with.

The fact that this book is on its fourth edition, having been first published in 1993, gives you a good hint as to the quality of this book. It is recommended.

Errata

PG 61 - Roger McKluskey should read Roger McCluskey.



BMC Competitions Department Secrets, by Peter Browning, Marcus Chambers, Stuart Turner and Philip Young.
ISBN: 978-1-849948-94-8, £24.99 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
BMC Competitions Department secrets was first published in 2005, but is reissued here as part of the Veloce Classic Reprint series, which is good news, as you can now pick up books which you missed the first time around.

This isn't a book if you are after narrative - it doesn't do lengthy descriptions of the rallies undertaken, making do with short chapters from each of the three department managers. But what it does do is to publish numerous internal memos and photographs, fleshing out from the companies point of view what was happening. And it is highly illuminating, showing what was concentrated on and thought important, and how things were done. For example, in order to short-cut customs bureaucracy, chassis plates and registration numbers were sometimes switched, so when taken together with cars which were re-shelled, it makes it somewhat difficult to work out whether a car which is claimed to have won a rally actually did so. Pity the poor historian....

Some of the memos though may require a magnifying glass to read, as a closely typed A4 page when reduced to letter size can be hard to read, and the reproduction for some isn't great, although that may also have something to do with the quality of the original paperwork being shown. Nevertheless, it is an informative an interesting view of what went on behind the scenes. One memo for the London to Sydney Marathon was particularly amusing in its content and innocence: "Suggest that it would be a wise precaution for each car to carry a small fire arm for some personal protection in the event of a breakdown or accident in remote parts. As most members of the team have already demonstrated their prowess at this art in the past, I am leaving each crew to make their own arrangements for the supply of suitable armoury." Apparantly weapons weren't taken in the end, but I have images of co-drivers with a long list of things to tick off before leaving: Map, check. Stop watch, check. Walther PPK, check..... You wouldn't see that in the WRC today.

Maybe the directives on firearms should have been taken on by the department managers, as it may have helped with the politics of the department closure, which is also described through various memos. These memos help to show the human effect of such decisions, bringing through the hurt and upset at having to disband and implement others decisions. It is worth the read, and a different take on how to describe the rallying world and teams.


Errata

PG 32 - 1955 Tulip Rally - #137 MG Magnette is captioned as being Geoff Holt. Holt drove #148, #137 was driven by Shaw/Lawton.

PG 41 - 1957 Liege-Rome-Liege Rally - Caption for top picture says that Pat Moss finished fourth - she was not fourth overall, she finished 23rd. Fourth in class perhaps?

PG 42 - 1958 Monte Carlo Rally - says that #317 was Brookes brothers. They drove #304 - #317 was Bremner/Oldworth.



Lotus 18 - Colin Chapman's U-turn, by Mark Whitelock.
ISBN: 978-1-845845-20-9, £50 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
The Lotus 18 wasn't the first rear engined car, and wasn't the most successful either, but it did win races, helping to build the reputation of Lotus in F1 as a winner, and it laid down the foundations (or should that be chassis members?) for more successful cars to come. It was raced in Formula 1 and 2, and a two seater variant was raced in sportscars. It was a versatile car.

So there is a lot to cover, which this book does in detail, mixing detailed photographs of suspension and car internals, with diagrams of chassis layouts and pictures from various races, sprinkled with short side pieces on the drivers who competed in them, the major circuits it competed on, and the teams which campaigned it. The book goes chronologically through each year in which the car competed, whether in F1 or the South African Gold Star series, before summarising each chassis history as far as they are known (and this is more difficult than may be imagined, with chassis plates being swapped to help avoid customs duties - read more in the book....). Quotes from the people involved are also used to help add more context to the prose.

There are many great images, and I think that the image on page 40 of Stirling Moss in a Cooper with wheels pointing at all angles while followed by Innes Ireland in an 18 with wheels perfectly upright, summarises exactly why it was such a good car. It wasn't really the u-turn suggested by the book title - when you are being beaten by a car with the same engine repeatedly then you take a look at why - the real development was the suspension and approach to frontal area. This can be seen clearly from the numerous diagrams and images throughout the book.

The book seems to assume a certain age of its readers, as things such as temperatures and measures are often given only in imperial, and I was taught entirely in metric. Also, some things are seen through a too much Lotus 18 centric prism. For instance, Goodwood for me isn't remembered for Innes Ireland's two wins there, significant though they were for the 18 (and as stated in the text) - instead it is remembered as the site of Bruce McLaren's fatal accident, and the career ending one for Stirling Moss. That last one was in a Lotus 18/21, another variant covered within the book.

In summary, the book is a well crafted history of a significant car in the development of Grand Prix racing. It is nicely laid out, and unusually for my last set of reviews, doesn't come with any errata. It's a good book....



The Argentine Temporada Motor Races 1950 to 1960, by Hernan Lopez Laiseca.
ISBN: 978-1-845848-28-6, £35 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
This was a much anticipated book, as it covers a part of motorsport history not often written about, but often hinted at. Although the Argentinian Grand Prix in Buenos Aires is well known, less well known are the series of events which made up the Temporada series, at different circuits throughout the country.

The tag line of the book gives a good description of how the book is laid out - "in 220 contemporary photos". The book is heavily photograph based, with many atmospheric photographs showing the drivers, the cars, and the events. However, the accompanying text although informative is a little terse, and as a result sometimes leaves a few questions hanging (as well as sometimes repeating the photograph captions). For example, on page 26 it says that after the 1950 Mar del Plata race, that "the relationship between the Italian and Argentinian press deteriorated and an incredible media battle ensued", but then says nothing more about it. Bearing in mind that this was before the era of instant communications, it would have been interesting to know how this developed and over how long, and whether it had any further long term effects. The terseness also extends to the concluding lines - having described the final race, there is one line saying that the golden age of Argentine motoring was over, with no enlightenment as to why or for what reasons the races were no longer held. A couple more lines are ideally needed.

Additionally, the book doesn't appear to cover all of the races which occurred in Argentina during this period, even if we take into account only single-seater events. Missing from 1950 is the Gran Premio de Paraná held on the 12th November 1950 at Parque Urquiza, Paraná. Missing also are any races from 1952, with the VI Gran Premio del General Juan Perón y de la Ciudad de Buenos Aires being held on the 9th March 1952 in Buenos Aires, and the VI Gran Premio Extraordinario de Eva Duarte Perón being held on the 16th March 1952 at the same venue. No indication is given as to why there was nothing reported for 1952, and it seems a strange omission. Also missing are the winning times for the single seater races, although they are given for the sportscar events. Otherwise full race results are given for all of the races reported.

In conclusion, it wasn't quite the book I hoped it would be. It has wonderful photographs, but the textual content is slightly flawed. However, it covers a series of races not generally covered elsewhere, so for that and the photo's it is still worth purchasing.


Errata

PG 125 - Gran Premio de la Republica Argentina. Missing #24 Adolfo Schwelm Cruz, who drove a Cooper-Bristol T20, DNF/20 laps/wheel off.

PG 125 - GP de BA - winner was Giuseppe Farina rather than José (a number of drivers have their names transcribed into the Spanish equivalent in other places too).

PG 130 - GP de BA - Was a two part race, and the race result given is the heat 1 result, not the aggregate overall result. Heat 2 and aggregate results are missing.



Grand Prix Ford - Ford, Cosworth and the DFV, by Graham Robson.
ISBN: 978-1-845846-24-4, £65.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
The DFV - three initials which for two decades ran through the veins of Formula 1. An engine which started in Formula 1, and spread throughout the motorsport world - this reviewer wrote an article on the engine, and many a book has been as well. It was so successful and so many built, that they even reached club racing, Dave Coyne's Lancia Stratos featuring a turbocharged version and being particularly memorable to this reviewer as it won it's race at Castle Combe when on fire and leading by almost a lap.

This book is well laid out and put together on high quality and weighty paper, and has a section for every single type of car which has ever raced in F1 with a DFV or derivative engine. There are many images, as well as a list of some of the other projects the engine was used for. It also includes brief biographies of key people in the engines' life story, such as Alan Mann, Harley Copp and Mike Kranefuss. It is encyclopaedic, but I couldn't help but notice that the author couldn't decide whether to use country codes or the full country names when giving the constructors, it randomly switching between them even for the same country. But that is the smallest of niggles, and is only noticable because of the high standard of the rest of the book. The book was originally started by Anthony Pritchard, but following his death was taken over and completed by Graham Robson, who expanded on the wording and the layout.

The book is about Ford, so would have been interesting to read more about how the success was viewed from the US headquarters, given that the drive for Total Performance came from there, and it had to be approved at board level. What drove their approval? How come they did it so quickly? Why did they continue funding the program for so long given that their image targets had been achieved, and that the marques they were competing against in the marketplace weren't competing in the same race series? If the subject is Ford, I would have liked to have seen more about the whole, rather than just the Ford Europe point of view.

The previously reviewed autobiography of Keith Duckworth makes an excellent companion volume to this book - read both, and you will have a good understanding of what happened and the people behind it. But this is the definitive guide to the DFV and derivative engined F1 cars, by an author who has met and spoken to most of the main actors over the years. It's a book I'd happily leave out on the coffee table for others to browse through, read bits and go "I remember that", or "Do you remember ?". The price might seem a little high, but the book is a limited edition of 1500 copies, and I imagine that they will go quickly - it's a book I will be returning to when I want to jog my memory on the subject, and few subjects in motorsport run over 25 years.....


Errata

PG 128, Col 1 - "March 86B F3000 car, which had just won the 1976 Championship". Should be 1986 Championship.

PG 147, Col 2 - "Way of optimising the 'ground effects' which Cosworth DFF runners...". Should be Cosworth DFV runners.

PG 154, Col 1 - "Onyx's co-founders, Mike Earls and....". Should read Mike Earle.

PG 195, Col 2 - "Nomally-aspirated teams would compete for..." Should read "Normally-aspirated".

PG 197 onwards - Williams type numbers frequently written FWO (with letter O) rather than FW0 (number 0).



Dino - The V6 Ferrari, by Brian Long.
ISBN: 978-1-904788-39-3, £40.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
The Dino to Formula 1 cogniscenti is the legendary 156 "Sharknose", the 1.5 litre car which Ferrari used to win the new engined formula 1 championship in 1961. But there were also a range of road cars which used the same name, and after reading this book I can honestly say that I know a whole lot more about them. It's also one of the few times I've seen the Ferrari type numbering system explained too.

The book has an elegant cover, quality paper and many sharp images, taking you briefly through the story of Ferrari before concentrating on anything which had a V6 engine, detailing the show cars presented at the motor shows as well as actual production vehicles, even quoting the detail differences between different mark runs of the same vehicle type. It runs through to the final V8 models, which given the title I guess is the exception which proves the rule! It also includes facsimiles of the product brochures from both Fiat and Ferrari, the book covering the Fiat Dino models as well.

Additionally included is a brief buyers' guide, running through the things to look out for when buying one, including a picture of a very sad looking example needing a lot of body work attention, but still costing in excess of £130,000 at 2015 auction prices - these cars aren't cheap. They also need more regular mechanical attention than a modern car, as you may expect, and services can take three days, so don't expect to buy one and have running costs like your every day car.

As a bonus, the book has even taught me new vocabulary - jounce - the compression part of a shock absorber cycle before you get the rebound. But perhaps that says more about me!

So, in short, the book is a detailed record of the Dino cars and the changes the underwent through its seven year run. If you own one or are looking into the history of them, then this is for you.

Errata(ish)

PG 10, column 1 "Ninth in the 1919 Targa [Florio]" - Ferrari did not finish, only completing 3 laps out of 4. Depends on whether you include DNFs as places, which wasn't usually done in period. Admittedly the reproduced CMN advert from that year says Ferrari was 3rd in class, so....



WSC Giants: Ferrari 333 SP, by Terry O'Neil.
ISBN: 978-1-845847-58-6, £16.99 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
When this book was first mentioned to me, it brought to mind pictures of scarlet Momo sponsored cars, usually in bright sunshine, which frequently appeared in Autosport through the long lifetime of the car. But minds play funny tricks on you, as I found when reading the book and looking at the pictures (and there are lots of them in this book - 141 of them in 122 pages!) - there were so many entries which weren't scarlet at all - I could remember the drivers, but the colour schemes of the cars not at all.

This book is a chronicle of the cars competition career, listing every race which was entered, together with the drivers, the results, and which chassis finished where, so it is a detailed log with small race descriptions. As the cars career was mainly focussed on the US racing scene, that is where the book concentrates, and it chronicles how US scene went from IMSA, through the USRRC, Professional Sports Car Racing to the ALMS, a period of of great turbulence in sportscar racing.

It is a good book (there are a couple of minor errors - on page 35, which covers the 1996 Sebring 12 Hrs, it says that a Porsche came down off the banking and collided with Baldi - Sebring is an airfield circuit and there is no banking) - it would have been a great book if the author could have interviewed the designers and asked them why they did some of the things they did, what made them accept this proposal and not others. And the drivers - how did they feel in the car, how did it compare to others in how it drove and handled? How was the car developed over time, and why? And a summary/overview of the career at the end would close the story better. But there is nothing else out there which chronicles the cars history, and it does it in detail. I liked it.



First Principles - The Official Biography of Keith Duckworth OBE, by Norman Burr.
ISBN: 978-1-845845-27-5, £35.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
Cosworth - if your were born at a certain time, it means the DFV, the engine which powered the garagistes who took on the factory teams with their own chassis. To the next generation, it means the RS500, the massively powerful Ford Sierra used in the British Touring Car Championship, on our screens every other weekend on BBC Grandstand showing flame spitting on turbo over-run as Robb Gravett, Andy Rouse and Laurence Bristow amongst others fought each other around the UK circuits, the race at the Birmingham Superprix particularly sticking in the mind. Later again it was the Ford Escort Cosworth, the rally car which was competed everywhere, carrying the likes of Francois Delecour and Malcolm Wilson. But although the name is well known, less well known are the founders, Mike Costin and Keith Duckworth. And even if the names are known, less is known about the men themselves.

And this is where this book comes in. The official biography of Keith Duckworth, it charts Keith's story from his family beginnings in Blackburn, through his school, University studies, the founding of the company and on through his various projects. The author has interviewed many of his fellow co-workers, and quotes them extensively through the text, together with many quotes from his family. And together they help to flesh out a feeling of who the man was, and how he operated. The author blends them into the narrative to help give a feel for why things were done as they were. Added to this are numerous personal photographs of the people involved, and the projects undertaken, which help to add colour to the text. The picture on the front cover of a young Keith Duckworth overlooking his engine design while talking to Colin Chapman really shows what he was about, and helps to convey more than text alone ever could.

In addition, the book doesn't exclusively focus on motorsport, as Cosworth was involved in many more projects than just F1, and it is all the better for that. But the reader should be aware when reading this book that this isn't just a biography of Duckworth, it also covers all of the projects that Cosworth was involved with during his time there, some of them of which Duckworth might only have been involved with in passing. But it is a good read. The only thing I would request is that when the book is reprinted, please can the footnotes be moved from the end of the chapters to the bottom of the page where they are used - this reviewer ended up having to bookmark the end of the chapter so that they could be read in context!



Competition car aerodynamics (3rd edition), by Simon McBeath.
ISBN: 978-1-845841-23-1, £40.00 (+ P&P).
Published by Veloce Publishing Ltd, 33 Trinity Street, Dorchester, Dorset, England, DT1 1TT.
Tel: +(0)1305 260068. Fax +(0)1305 268864.
E-mail: sales@veloce.co.uk. www.veloce.co.uk.

Click here to order or see a sample
"Wow" was the first response upon unpacking this book when it arrived. It has weight, the design lends it gravitas, and on flicking through the pages (which are on high quality paper) there were lots of impressive looking diagrams - it looks authoritative.

The book isnít afraid to use maths to explain things (although this reviewer thinks that one of the worked examples is incorrect Ė see the addendum to this review), but this shouldnít put a prospective reader off. The maths help to explain what the CFD examples are showing and why, and what the CFD algorithms are doing. And that is the point of this book Ė an explanation of how things work and how to apply them to your race car, whether it is a saloon car or single seater. It doesnít aim to give you exact figures and tell you where to place your new wing, but instead an idea of where to look and how to go about deducing what would work best, together with methodologies for testing your newly discovered setup.

So yes, the book is authorative, and well worth a read for those who want to understand the why when looking at the latest aerodynamic designs in motorsport. It works whether you are in interested viewer, or whether you are looking at pointers for building your own car. And although I donít have a car of my own, Iíd love to sit in on a session at MIRA when the author was testing one of the cars featured in the book!


Addendum
The equation on page 133 for balancing front and rear wings based on weight distribution reads:

Which is missing brackets to begin with, confusing the equation. It should read:

The example says that the 1/2ρ and V2 cancel each other out as they are on both sides of the equation, but mathematically thatís not true as these values are not in both terms on both side of the equation. So, letís get rid of some of the fractions, to make the next steps easier. Firstly, the 38/62:

Letís get rid of the fractions, so multiply all by 124:

Rearranging to get the same terms on each side:

And taking out the common factors:

Rearranging to give:

Taking ρ (air density) to be 1.225 kgm-3, Afront to be 0.4 m2, Arear to be 0.5885 m2, and assuming a velocity of 60 ms-1 (the 217 kph maximum speed of the car), together with a CLrear of 2.95, we get a CLfront value of 1.81, which is substantially smaller than the 2.67 value calculated.

Actually, because the V2 component is so big, the first term is tiny, and hence if you ignored the first part, you end up with an equation in which the front coefficient is simply the rear multiplied by the weight distribution fraction.


Update
Following clarification with the author, who was kind enough to discuss this in detail, what we have in the equation on page 133 is a confusion between a subtraction and a negative number. So -CL means negative CL, in which case the two terms do cancel out as suggested, and the quoted values are correct. Thank you for taking the time to point this out!


Please note that all of the opinions stated here are mine.....